Gail's Homepage

Home

U.S. Army-Baylor University Graduate Program in Health Care Administration | About Me | Favorite Links | Contact Me | My Pets | Vacation Photo Album | My Resume | Breast Cancer
Health Care Systems

Dealing with Language Barrier in the Health Service System

Introduction

 

It is an accepted belief in the United States Healthcare System that a language barrier between a provider and patient can affect the appropriateness, effectiveness, and equity of that patients medical care.   Due to the complexity of medicine, good communication between a provider and patient can be difficult even when there is a common language and culture.  When there exist only a few common words or gestures for communication, the risk of misdiagnosis increases dramatically.   The U.S. Health Services system has an obligation to provide quality and equal care to all its patients.  The U. S.  Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights has classified inadequate interpretation in the healthcare setting as a form of discrimination Baker et al. (1996).

The demographics of the United States emphasize the necessity for improving our communication capabilities with ethnic minorities.  According to the 1990 census, 32 million non-English-speaking people reside in the country.  Of those people, nearly 14 million rate their English language ability as less than well and more than 1.8 million cannot speak English at all.  These numbers are projected to increase.  The Asian population is increasing faster than the total US population and the Hispanic population is growing 53% faster than the total population. Dreger, V. & Tremback, T. (2002). These numbers emphasize the magnitude of the issue.

The importance of this issue is reflected in government and organizational regulations pertaining to this issue.  As early as 1964, Title VI of the Civil Right Act prohibited discrimination by all medical professionals toward ethnic minority patients who receive Medicaid, Medicare Part A, or other government money Dreger et al. (2002).  In 2000, Former President Bill Clinton issued an executive order directing all federal programs to make accommodations for patients linguistic background.  Both JCAHO and the American Hospital Association require hospitals to have methods for providing effective communication for every patient to include those with language barriers Gravely and S. (2001). Medical facilities have an obligation to meet these requirements and they have a responsibility to provide efficient, effective and equitable care.  The question is how can medical facilities meet these requirements?  This paper reviews three articles that explore different methods for upholding these imperatives.  Breene (1999) explores a number of options for meeting these standards for our ethnic minority patients.

Baylor studies